Rep. Massie Debates Iran War Powers Resolution
Floor debate on the bipartisan war powers resolution Massie introduced with Ro Khanna to prohibit U.S. military involvement against Iran without a declaration of war.
Original by RepThomasMassie on YouTube ↗ · Is this you? Claim credit →
Chapters
Transcript
Click any timestamp to jump to that moment.
- The gentleman from New York is recognized. >> Yeah, I'm happy to yield 5 minutes to the gentleman from Kentucky and the sponsor of this important resolution,
- the honorable representative Thomas Massie. Gentleman from Kentucky is recognized. I thank the gentleman from New York. Mr. Speaker, James Madison wrote to Thomas Jefferson in 1789, "The
- Constitution supposes what the history of all governments demonstrates, that the executive branch of power is the most interested in war and most
- prone to it. It has accordingly with studied care vested the question of war in the legislature." The Constitution is clear. Article 1,
- Section 8, Clause 11 of our Constitution provides Congress initiatory powers of war. Article 2, Section 2, Clause 1 of
- our Constitution gives the president operational powers of war to wage that war. Even if this body were to pretend
- that the 1973 War Powers Resolution precedes the clear language of the Constitution, the president still has not met the conditions required by that
- law itself. The 1973 War Powers Resolution states plainly that the president may only introduce US armed forces into
- hostilities pursuant to three conditions: either one, declaration of war; two, specific statutory
- authorization; or three, a national emergency created by an attack upon the United States. None of those conditions exist today. Iran has not attacked the
- United States, Congress has not declared war, and Congress has not granted specific statutory authorization. Beyond the constitutional question, here lies
- an even more important one. Why are we going to war with Iran? We owe our military service members a clear
- mission. And American families in my district want to know how's this is going to help them pay for groceries? How does this make them any safer in their schools or
- in their neighborhoods? How does this help them pay for housing? Have we learned nothing from the laundry list of wars and regime change experiments we
- sparked across the Middle East that have racked up a total of at least $8 trillion of debt in Iraq, Libya, Syria, Afghanistan?
- A sustained war with Iran will not stabilize the region. It's already ignited the region. It will radicalize new generations of
- terrorists, and it will send more swarms of refugees into Europe and the United States. Iran is not Venezuela. The Ayatollah was not a president. He was a
- religious leader from a region notorious for radical Islamist, and the United States and Israel turned him into a martyr. And in the process of doing so,
- we've already expended billions of dollars, and more solemnly, six American families must now lay to rest their sons and daughters. And for what? This administration can't
- even give us a straight answer as to why we launched this preemptive war. The president says we had to strike first because an Iranian strike was imminent.
- Meanwhile, the Department of Defense conceded there was no evidence of an imminent Iranian strike. Some told us this war was about nuclear
- weapons, but 6 months ago we were assured our last strike on Iran decimated their nuclear program. So, which is it?
- I think the most candid answer came from the Secretary of State who told the press that Israel forced our hand and dragged us into this war.
- Again. And that truth is the very reason why it is Congress that must decide war. If American lives are to be risked and
- American blood is to be shed, that decision must be debated and voted on by the representatives of the American people, and that debate is meant to be
- arduous, and that vote is meant to be hard. I have a theory. I think my colleagues don't want to go on record because we have a terrible
- track record of meddling in the Middle East. They don't want their name associated with this when it doesn't turn out well. But Congress cannot be bothered with its
- constitutional duty because for many in this chamber, it's easier to simply allow someone else's sons and daughters to be sent to combat
- without their vote. And to be clear, we aren't even here to declare war today. All we're voting on is a War Powers Resolution to reassert the Constitution
- that Congress must decide questions of war. And if Congress wants war, then the speaker should hold a vote to declare it. Some say Congress authorizes war
- when we pay for it, when we pass the budget bill. Here's the problem. We haven't taken on the hard work of defining the mission for our sons and
- daughters who are going to fight. That's not in the budget bill. It never is. And to the men and women who are engaged in combat, I sincerely thank you, and I
- pray for your safety. It is for you that I wrote this resolution. It is for you that all of us are here on this floor working so hard
- to force this vote so that you will have a clear mission that you deserve. So that you will know when you achieve it, you can come home. And with that, I urge
- support for this resolution, and I yield back.